**NYC’s Soft Discipline Policy Fails to Restore School Order**

Imagine trying to pacify a storm by whispering to it. Sounds absurd, right? Yet, New York City’s schools have been attempting something remarkably similar, and the results, as a new study reveals, are far from calm.

What’s Happening?

New York City’s “restorative justice” policy, aiming to reduce suspensions and expulsions, has reportedly backfired. Schools are facing increased disorder, violence, and chronic absenteeism.

Where Is It Happening?

Public schools across New York City.

When Did It Take Place?

The policy was implemented in 2022, and the study’s findings are based on the current academic year.

How Is It Unfolding?

– Violent incidents have doubled to 4,200 reports.
– Chronic absenteeism has reached an all-time high.
– Teachers report feeling unsupported and demoralized.
– Some schools are reverting to stricter discipline policies.
– The city’s investment of $100 million appears to have little positive impact.

Quick Breakdown

– **Policy**: “Restorative justice” over strict discipline.
– **Outcome**: Increased violence and absenteeism.
– **Cost**: $100 million investment.
– **Teachers’ Sentiment**: Feelings of unsupported and demoralized.
– **Current Trend**: Some schools are reverting to stricter policies.

Key Takeaways

New York City’s bold experiment with “restorative justice” has not yielded the desired results. Instead of fostering a more equitable and orderly environment, the policy has seemingly contributed to chaos. The doubling of violent incidents and record-high absenteeism suggest that the approach may have overlooked the importance of clear boundaries and accountability. It’s a stark reminder that education policies, no matter how well-intentioned, must be carefully designed and continually assessed to ensure they effectively address the complex realities of school environments.

Final Thought

**The path to fostering a safe and productive learning environment is complex and multifaceted. While the principles of restorative justice are commendable, the recent findings in NYC highlight the critical need to balance these principles with structured accountability and support systems. The ongoing conversation surrounding this issue should focus on creating a harmonious blend of equity, discipline, and student well-being, ensuring that our schools remain sanctuaries of growth and development for every child.**

Read More

Post Views: 1